J&J Found to Have Improperly Destroyed Vaginal-Mesh Files

By Jef Feeley(Feb 5, 2014 3:22 PM CT)

Johnson & Johnson (JNJ) improperly destroyed files about some vaginal-mesh implants and may have to let juries weighing lawsuits over the devices hear evidence about the destruction, a court official said.

J&J’s Ethicon unit, which made Gynecare Prolift and TVT Retropubic meshes, lost or destroyed thousands of documents and computer files about the development of the devices from as far back as 2007, Cheryl Eifert, a U.S. magistrate judge in Charleston, West Virginia, concluded yesterday. Suits over the devices are consolidated there for pre-trial hearings.

The finding comes as J&J prepares to face its first trial Feb. 10 in West Virginia over claims the TVT Retropubic sling, used to support women’s internal organs, eroded and shrank over time, causing pain and injuries. J&J, based in New Brunswick, New Jersey, is facing more than 12,000 federal-court claims over the TVT Retropubic and its other vaginal-mesh inserts.

Ethicon officials acknowledged their document-retention system “failed miserably in certain instances” to properly preserve vaginal-mesh files, Eifert said. She recommended that U.S. District Judge Joseph Goodwin, who is overseeing the consolidated cases, allow women suing J&J to tell jurors about the loss of documents if they can show the destruction put them at a disadvantage.

“While Ethicon produced millions of pages of documents in the MDL, it did inadvertently fail to preserve some documents, many of which were available elsewhere” in files that were turned over to women suing over the implants, Matthew Johnson, an Ethicon spokesman, said today in an e-mailed statement.

File Management

In her report, Eifert said there was no evidence Ethicon officials deliberately sought to keep vaginal-mesh files out of court. They documents were destroyed after employees left the company as part of Ethicon’s file-management system, she said.

Still, Eifert found Ethicon officials were negligent in their mishandling of the files and should be punished by allowing some juries to hear about the document destruction. The magistrate’s recommendations must be reviewed by Goodwin before they become final.

The consolidated case is In Re Ethicon Pelvic Repair System Products Liability Litigation, 12-MD-02327, U.S. District Court, Southern District of West Virginia (Charleston). The case set for trial Feb. 10 is Lewis v. Johnson & Johnson, 12-cv-04301, U.S. District Court, Southern District of West Virginia (Charleston).

To contact the reporter on this story: Jef Feeley in Wilmington, Delaware at jfeeley@bloomberg.net

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Recent Articles

Truck Accident Injuries – When to Call an Alabama Big Truck Accident Lawyer
April 5, 2023
Why Do Car Accidents Increase During The Holidays?
December 1, 2022
Don’t Ignore Your Pain After a Car Accident
October 12, 2022
Johnny Smith
Johnny Smith
21:19 10 Feb 22
When I met Ed Rowan, my family and I were in a dispute with a very large and nationally recognized company. From the... start, I could tell we were in good hands. His immediate grasp of the case, including the most minute details was refreshing. Within a few weeks, I found that skill and a good memory were only two of Ed’s attributes. He is also honest, hardworking, and extremely motivated to win. The successful resolution of our case far exceeded my expectations. Ed Rowan has proved himself to me. He will be my first call for any legal issues I have in the future.read more
Noelle L.
Noelle L.
22:11 23 Jan 22
My family and I had a very positive experience with this law firm. Our attorney worked so hard on our behalf. We were... extremely happy with the outcome. I would highly recommend this firm to others that are looking for help. Thank you for making this a positive experience for us. We had other things to worry about. This firm took our legal worries away. Thank you, again, for your service.read more
Jordan Davis
Jordan Davis
13:24 20 Aug 19
Love the whole legal team at Taylor Martino. They truly care about their clients. Would not go to any another Injury... Lawyer in Alabama!read more
Kiyyah Malik
Kiyyah Malik
19:09 13 Jun 19
Ben Kearns and the staff at Taylor Martino made a terrible situation (car accident) into a much simpler less stressful... process. I appreciate all the dedication and hard work. They are highly recommended in my book!read more
Shadow Yuuki
Shadow Yuuki
20:04 22 May 19
These guys are the best. If anyone needs a lawyer, they did what they said they where going to do and when they said... they going to do it i got everything i should have. They are the best lawyers in Mobileread more
Rachel
Rachel
21:34 20 May 19
I heard about Ed Rowan from my aunt and gave him a call. Ed Rowan got things done in a timely matter and Elizabeth... Wright was very helpful and quick to respond when I had any questions.read more
Tim Howard
Tim Howard
15:11 23 Sep 18
I highly recommend the firm as they took my case and settled it quickly. They took me in and treated me like family... from day one. They kept me informed throughout the process and never left me feeling uncomfortable. Ben and Jennifer went above and beyond what anyone would expect.read more
sree harsha sunkara
sree harsha sunkara
15:14 13 Apr 18
This was the best law firm I have ever experienced. All I did was just contacted them and they did the rest for me and... updated me every week about the work in process. They were so good and I highly recommend them in case of any accidentsread more
Alice Dobson
Alice Dobson
12:17 19 Oct 17
No one ever wants to find themselves in need of an attorney, however, if needed you should contact Taylor Martino. ... They all worked very hard on my case and got me a much bigger settlement than I ever expected. I hope to never be in need of a lawyer again but if I do, I'll be calling them.read more
Laura V
Laura V
03:09 13 Oct 17
I had a family member use this firm a couple months ago and dealt with Richard Taylor. He was very professional and... compassionate. He went above and beyond to make sure my family was informed and felt confident in their situation. I would recommend this firm to anyone!read more
debra hadley
debra hadley
02:49 15 Dec 15
Ed Rowan was very knowledgeable, professional and truly cared about my case. He was diligent in pursuing my case as if... I was his only client. He kept me informed from the beginning to end and was always willing to listen and answer my questions.Give him a call he is excellent.read more
More reviews